Musicians should embrace carry-on baggage fees

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no cost to you.

People are outraged over an airline’s announcement that its cheapest fares will no longer cover carry-on baggage. (This isn’t the first time that airlines have charged fees for carry-on bags.)

My experience flying with musical instruments as carry-ons has been stressful at best. This passage from an economics textbook rings true to me:

photo, Bradley Gordon

The battle begins in the gate where air travelers elbow their way to the front of the line to board the aircraft as soon as possible in order to grab an overhead bin. Once on the aircraft, the real fight begins. Some passengers with seats in the rear of the plane toss their bags into the front compartments to be sure they get a spot. People with oversized bags cram them into the narrow bins, pushing the bags, coats, and hats of passengers with correctly sized luggage into the corners. People ask for help from the flight attendants but their pleas are ignored. The flight attendants say they are too short staffed to handle passenger disagreements concerning bags. Losers are left standing with their “homeless” bags. …

Are people just selfish and rude? Most economists say no, they are just responding to the absence of market incentives. The overhead bins are a commons. It’s Dodge City. Nobody “owns” the space in the overhead bins. People can’t trust strangers to act with cooperation or courtesy. The result is “warfare.”

Things could be different. Creating an overhead bin market would bring out the best of people. Here is how. Most of today’s airlines charge people extra to check a bag and offer the overhead bins for “free.” It should be just the reverse.

Nobody likes paying more. But a carry-on fee is a small percentage of an airline ticket. And for most musicians it’s a small price to pay for better access (maybe even guaranteed access!) to the overhead storage. Is it worth the price of a box of reeds or two to know my saxophone will arrive in one piece? Or the price of a pound or two of cane to ensure that my bassoon reaches its destination? I think so.


One response to “Musicians should embrace carry-on baggage fees”

  1. Sarah Dale Avatar
    Sarah Dale

    I think if you have the option to purchase more space than your “allotted” carry-ons you have now, I could get behind this – Event if it was $100 for a 3rd carry on so I can safely get my tenor in the overhead I’d do it.

    Otherwise I always purchase a seat towards the back of the plane so I am one of those first people on and with airlines like AIr Canada, if you go to the gate and explain you are a musician they will let you be one of the first people on.

    I haven’t flown that much, but to say in 20+ flights I’ve never had an issue with getting my horns on I usually travel with Alto, flute, clarinet, pic – so luckily non of the bigger horns which helps a LOT. I usually can’t get all that AND a tenor in the cabin, so I stopped flying with my tenor.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments that take a negative or confrontational tone are subject to email and name verification before being approved. In other words: no anonymous trolls allowed—take responsibility for your words.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.